top of page

It's A Wonderful Lie

Writer: Chris O'Rourke
Chris O'Rourke
21 minutes ago
5 min read

AI Image created with ChatGPT


Honesty was dead, to begin with. There is no doubt whatever about that. Stonewalled behind a silence thicker than a Dickensian fog. Meanwhile, Dublin scrubs up nicely for the festive season. Twinkling lights reigniting the annual love-hate relationship with Wham!, Christmas shopping in November, and the perennial joy of dancing Santas. Traversing familiar streets, amidst homeless and unwanted souls, an eager audience gathers for the opening night of It’s a Wonderful Lie — sorry, Life — at The Gate Theatre. Across the way, three abandoned theatre lovers huddle close as a promise of frost whispers across the pavement. Oliver Twist, The Little Match Girl and yours truly. Chilled to the bone while, inside The Gate’s cozy auditorium, the good people of Bedford Falls enact angel wings and Christmas tidings issuing waves of human kindness. Seeing Tiny Tim hobble tearfully down a darkened lane, having been turned away, Ollie, as is his fawning manner, meekly approaches the door. Like Tiny Tim, we are no longer welcome and have been denied admission.

“Please, can I have some more?” Oliver begs, like the good boy he is.


Silence, heavy with arrogance. The Little Match Girl sniggers in disgust.


“Sell me a box of those, will you? I’m thinking of burning some bridges,” I muse softly.


“On the house.” Her eyes, steely with resolve, hold my gaze as she coughs consumptively. “And don’t just burn bridges. Scorch the earth if you have to.”


“Happy Christmas to you, too.”


“I mean it. If the powers supposed to represent what’s best in theatre want to shut us down to shut us up, then go out swinging. I’d do it myself if I had strength left in me. If only for those too afraid to speak.” She rises gingerly. “Do not go quietly in that dark night. Rage, rage against the murder of the light. Even if it’s the last thing you do.”


“Might prove to be.”


I watch her disappear down the narrow lane after Tiny Tim, the dejected Oliver running behind, trying to catch up.


The matchbox is damp, but the matches are dry.


I take one out, look at it a moment, then strike.


Long established, highly respected, unequivocally trusted and mildly irreverent, TheArtsReview has been shining its critical light on Irish theatre for well over a decade. Robust, detailed, informed and in-depth criticism, along with reviews published by the now-defunct Examiner.com, amounting to an ongoing archive of more than 1,300 documents of record covering 15 years of dance, opera and theatre across Ireland. Its monthly global readership matching, or exceeding, that of any equivalent, online or otherwise. At a time when print media is cutting its word count and the number of reviews it publishes, with what is published locked behind a paywall, when alternates available online are often of mixed quality, TheArtsReview offers detailed, rigorous criticism at no cost. So what does it tell us when a critical standard bearer is no longer invited to review at The Gate? No warning. No courtesy call. No viable explanation, despite requests. Nothing beyond:


The Gate recently reviewed their press invitation numbers, which unfortunately has resulted in a smaller number of media invitations being issued.


Yet why TheArtsReview? Because it's no longer good enough? Or is the rumour doing the rounds more likely? Something I'd been forewarned of by several sources, and which has been unanimously endorsed by all those I've spoken to. Namely, that The Gate, apparently unhappy with yet another three-star review, this time for Meredith, along with some fair, if unenthusiastic criticism of over recent years, allegedly took the decision to cancel TheArtsReview. To toss it into the street during the festive season, Bah Humbugging all requests for clarification.


If true, even if not, what does it say when a government-funded theatre, which claims critics are vital to theatre’s ecosystem and expound core values of inclusivity, diversity, equality, integrity and transparency, as well as claiming to offer purposeful cultural leadership by promoting critical voices for the oppressed decides to censor and silence a respected critical outlet without warning, explanation or accountability?


AI Image created with ChatGPT


True, TheArtsReview has no divine right to review anywhere. And perhaps The Gate is right. Perhaps, despite its huge popularity, TheArtsReview is a relic of a bygone era. No longer relevant in a world of soundbite, shrinking print media, the sometimes hit-and-miss synopses passing as online reviews, and the recent arrival of the AI critic embraced with open arms (AI will be part of the future, but I think it’s illegal not to acknowledge using it, it’s certainly immoral to pass it off as original work, as is happening). AI’s quotable quotes, cited by publicists on posters and social media, reinforcing the distrust of online criticism. Like the influencer at The Abbey’s Mission Critical, proudly stating that criticism is about working your Insta. So popular he doesn’t even review a show during its run, and only says nice things. Perhaps detailed, informed, in-depth criticism that promotes critical conversations, is freely available and beautifully written (aside from grammar, spelling, sentence structure, etc.), no longer has a place in Irish theatre’s ecosystem?


It certainly doesn’t appear to have a place at The Gate.


Bitter? No. Disappointed? Yes. Surprised? Hell no. It is a shame, though, that a national institution like The Gate can mistreat significant stakeholders it does not approve of with toxic, demeaning, degrading and discourteous disregard, whilst also claiming to be a cultural leader and defender of the marginalised and minorities. The irony, though others might choose a different word, biblical. TheArtsReview represents independent, outsider voices. Disruptive, maverick, critical thinkers. It makes informed criticism fun, interesting, sexy, and in not seeking to be monetised, that little bit dangerous. Well, it tries to at least. Still, what do I know? All I know for sure is that a respected, long-standing, hugely popular critical outlet has been dropped without explanation by a publicly funded theatre. The flabbergasted consensus being that it’s because it won’t play ball. Review the show, don’t review us, for if you do there’s many an actor or director can finish that sentence for you. TheArtsReview, apparently, made an example of to show what will happen if you upset the status quo.


I've enjoyed lots of good times reviewing at The Gate. I’m extremely fond of the place, and it’s mostly marvellous people. I've celebrated their work often. I might well have celebrated It's A Wonderful Life, and its talented hardworking cast and creatives. If I did, you'd know I meant it because I never shirk from saying what I feel needs to be said, be it good or bad. But we'll never know.


Stand up to Goliath, call the Emperor naked; what do I expect will happen next? So glad you asked. Flying online and solo, TheArtsReview makes for an easy target. Maybe it’ll crash and burn. Maybe we’ll kiss and make up. Who knows? But this article was never about TheArtsReview’s future. It’s about theatre-makers ostracised, silenced, or fearful of reprisals for not toeing the line by those in positions of power. It’s about a readership demanding robust criticism to advance critical conversations. It’s about the next generation of young critics, of whom I’m privileged to have mentored and published several (smart ones who don’t need to pass AI off as their own work). It’s about taking a stand when many can’t for fear of losing careers. It’s about refusing censorship, silence or elective criticism being forced upon us by cultural heavyweights who brazenly claim to represent the opposite.


I pocket the remaining matches.


The fire is burning now.


There’s lots to see in its revealing glow.


From the flickering shadows, fallen angels who might never get their wings inch closer. Theatre’s damned, defeated and undefeated. Its battered, broken and bewildered. Its ostracised, outsiders and outliers. The heartbroken, the trouble makers, the punished, the silenced. The rebellious, unrepentant, freethinkers.


They gather round.


Lots of them.


Huddling closer.


The Little Match Girl smiles as Tiny Tim, ever eager to have the last word, declares;


"Merry Christmas all. God bless us, every one."

 
 
Recent Posts
Follow Us
  • Facebook Basic Square
  • Twitter Basic Square
bottom of page